I’ve spent the past few weeks reading about privacy, identity, and reputation so that I can try to resolve a few questions I have about where I want to take my PhD research. My area of interest is reputation, but with so many elements impacting reputation it can be hard to interpret the map with all of my thoughts and ideas.
I admit that it’s been frustrating because I’ve found myself heading down so many paths that have been filled with more distraction than relevance and I was starting to wonder if I’d ever find a path that could bring me a bit more focus. (I understand this is a common problem at the start of a PhD, so I haven’t felt like a failure because of it – but it hasn’t built up my confidence, either.)
Thankfully, this is where my supervisors come in! They’ve “been there; done that” so they can help guide me in the right direction. (Yay!)
I developed a rough draft of an essay on privacy, identity, and reputation – and the relationship between the three – and sent my supervisors a copy ahead of yesterday’s supervision meeting. I was unhappy with the draft because it seemed [enter several negative adjectives here], but in the end, it was a very useful tool because one of my supervisors took the time to write a summary of key points on a whiteboard for us to discuss – and that discussion led to some useful waypoints.
By the end of the meeting, I was filled with a renewed sense of excitement because I could see the path a little more clearly. There is still a bit of fog and I’m sure there will be a few rough patches to traverse, but I feel that this path will lead me to a couple of major roads before too long.
Moving forward, I will start to look a bit more at the idea of online identities and their relationship with reputation – and I’ll try to remember that my PhD is not about privacy*. I’ll be investigating issues of multiple identities (personas/personalities) including pseudonyms and anonymous accounts and how they’re used in an online environment – as well as some of the recent discussions around requirements for the use of “real names” by organisations like Google and Huffington Post.
I hope to have a bit more clarity on my research soon, at which time I will try to be a bit less vague in what I’m sharing. In the meantime, if you have any great resources you wish to share with me on reputation and identity, please feel free to contact me or comment below!
* I’ll talk about my desire to keep privacy on the fringe of my research later – after I’ve clarified it all a bit more in my own mind.